Thriftmas shopping: A budget-friendly way to spread Christmas cheer

Once considered a niche hobby, thrifting has surged in popularity—fueled by economic concerns, a growing interest in sustainability, and the thrill of finding one-of-a-kind treasures. 

Gen Z and Millennials are leading the charge of thrift shopping’s renaissance in recent years. According to a report by ThredUp, an online thrift marketplace, secondhand shopping is expected to grow 127% by 2026. 

The trend aligns with shifting consumer values, including a desire to reduce waste and save money.

Shoppers can save 50% to 80% on items by buying secondhand. A vintage scarf that might cost $40 at a boutique could be found for less than $5 at a thrift store, and holiday decorations like wreaths and ornaments often cost just a few dollars.

“Thrift shopping not only saves money but also helps the environment," says Grace Sponseller-Young, owner of Gracelyn’s Goodies Thrift Boutique & Consignment in Shepherd. "It's like treasure hunting. You save money, find treasures and keep things out of landfills.”

The Mt. Pleasant area has several local thrift stores for shoppers to scour for deals—including these six thrift shops. 

Photo courtesy Gracelyns GoodiesGracelyn’s Goodies Thrift Boutique & Consignment is located at 362 W. Wright Avenue in Shepherd.Gracelyn’s Goodies ​​Thrift Boutique & Consignment

Opened in November 2022, Gracelyn’s Goodies Thrift Boutique & Consignment offers an assortment of women’s, men’s, and children’s clothing, accessories, and household items. 

Opening this store, located at 362 W. Wright Avenue in Shepherd, was a dream of owner Grace Sponseller-Young. The 24-year-old Shepherd native says she has always loved thrift shopping. She grew up doing it with her mom.

Gracelyn’s Goodies accepts donations of gently used clothing and home goods on consignment. The shop is filled to the brim with the latest styles displayed like top-fashion department stores. Inventory is a collection of consigned merchandise, along with items personally curated by Sponseller-Young and some handmade goodies from local vendors. Finds on unique merchandise makes this store a thrifters delight. 

Shopper tip: Note the store hours being closed Monday and Tuesday. Recently moving to the current location has expanded space and allowed room to offer men’s apparel and children’s clothing, too. 

Check out Gracelyn’s Goodies Facebook page for information on consignments.

Courtney Jerome / Epicenter Mt. PleasantThe ICDC Thrift Shop is located at 10008 W. High Street in Mt. Pleasant.
The ICDC Thrift Shop 

The Thrift Shop, located at 1008 W. High Street next to Gillroy’s Hardware in Mt. Pleasant, offers more than just deals. Opened in 1969, the shop supports the Isabella Child Development Center by providing free preschool to three and four-year-old children in Isabella County.

The store is packed with donated items and staffed by friendly volunteers, including a big assortment of gently used clothes for all ages, along with small household items, bedding, home decor, books, toys, shoes, and jewelry. You won’t find large electronics or furniture. 

Shopper tip: During the last week of every month most items are half off.  

Courtney Jerome / Epicenter Mt. PleasantLocated at 201 E. Pickard Road in Mt. Pleasant, the ReStore is another Isabella County-based thrift store.
Habitat for Humanity Isabella County’s ReStore

Habitat for Humanity Isabella County has been assisting people with housing needs in the community since 1989. The ReStore opened in 2008. Located at 201 E. Pickard Rd., the store helps fund the construction and repair of homes to shelter individuals and families in need throughout Isabella County. 

The ReStore’s inventory is a collection of donated items from builders and community members. 

You’ll find home building items from flooring to lighting, cabinets and everything else … including the kitchen sink. Gently used furniture, tools and household goods are also available. 

The Restore offers pick-up service for large donations. To schedule a pick up call 989-773-0043.

Shopper tip: This is a spot to find gifts for the handyman, furniture flippers, and home decorators on your holiday shopping list.

Courtney Jerome / Epicenter Mt. PleasantThe Salvation Army Family Store can be found at 1717 S. Mission Street in Mt. Pleasant.
The Salvation Army Family Store

The Salvation Army Family Store, fondly referred to as “Sal Val” to avid thrifters, is located at 1717 S. Mission Street. The retail store and donation center offers a large assortment of clothing for all ages, including furniture, toys, and household goods at affordable prices. 

Proceeds from the store support Salvation Army’s programs, including food assistance, shelter, and other essential services for those in need. The store is always well-stocked and organized. 

Shopper tip: Shop the color tag of the day for 50%-off prices. 

Courtney Jerome / Epicenter Mt. PleasantOne of the newest resale shops in Mt. Pleasant, Reynolds Golden Finds is located at 601 N. Fancher Street.
Reynolds Golden Finds

Reynolds Golden Finds is one of the newest spots for resale deals in town. Located on the corner of Andre and Fancher Street at 601 N. Fancher Street, the retailer is a bit different from other thrift stores. It’s a liquidation reseller, offering overstocked items from major retailers. Unlike thrift shops, Reynolds sells brand-new merchandise. 

Prices are deeply discounted and the inventory changes often. Shopping this store is truly a treasure hunt. Read more about Reynolds Golden Finds here. 

Shopper tip: Shop often as the inventory changes frequently. 

Courtney Jerome / Epicenter Mt. PleasantLocated at 4529 E. Bluegrass Road, the Goodwill Store in Mt. Pleasant offers a selection of second-hand items.
Goodwill in Mt. Pleasant

Goodwill is among the most popular thrift stores in the country with more than 4,000 retail outlets across the U.S. 

Founded in 1902, Goodwill Industries sells donated goods to support its mission of job training and placement to assist people in building better lives. For every dollar spent, 90 cents goes toward training and finding jobs for those in need in local communities. 

The stores are well-stocked, organized, and employ helpful associates who are happy to wrap your breakable treasure to avoid breakage. The Mt. Pleasant store, located at 4529 E. Bluegrass Road, has a selection of second-hand items that include clothing, books, household goods, electronics, and lots more. You’ll also find a section of new overstocked merchandise at deeply discounted prices. 

Shopper tip: Sign up for the rewards program and earn points for every $1 spent, redeemable for future purchases. Get coupons via text, sent three-four times per month through “Goodwill GR.”

Photo courtesy Gracelyns Goodies

Tips for Scoring the Best Thrift Deals

1. Go early: Thrift stores often restock in the morning, so arriving early gives you the first pick.
2. Shop when you have time to peruse everything in the store.
3. Come prepared with a list of items you’re shopping for so it’s not overwhelming.
4. Check store hours: some stores have limited hours and not open certain days of the week.
5. Be open-minded: Flexibility can lead to unexpected gems.
6. Look for discounts: Many stores offer special deals on certain days of the week.
7. Inspect items closely: Check for damages and ensure items are in usable condition.

What to Buy & What to Skip

Best Items to Buy:

• Holiday decor: Vintage ornaments, unique candleholders, and garlands.
• Books: Perfect for avid readers in the family.
• Kitchenware: Mugs, serving platters, and utensils make thoughtful gifts.
• Clothing: High-quality scarves, hats, or even vintage party dresses.
• Toys: Gently used puzzles and board games.

Items to Avoid:

• Electronics: They may not work properly and often lack warranties.
• Mattresses: These can harbor pests or allergens.
• Personal care items: Avoid used cosmetics or toiletries for hygiene reasons.
• Cribs or car seats: Safety standards change frequently, making older models risky.

Gift Ideas for Everyone on Your List

1. For the Chef: A vintage cast-iron skillet or unique kitchen gadgets.
2. For the Bookworm: A curated selection of classic novels or a beautiful bookend set.
3. For the Fashionista: Vintage jewelry or designer pieces.
4. For Kids: Wooden toys or educational board games.
5. For the Homebody: Cozy blankets or ceramic mugs paired with hot cocoa packets.

Cleaning Thrifted Items Before Giving 

Before gifting, be sure thrifted items are clean and presentable. Here’s how:

• Clothing: Wash in hot water or dry clean to remove odors and stains.
• Hard Goods: Wipe down with a mixture of vinegar and water or disinfectant wipes.
• Books: Dust the pages and covers gently.
• Plush Toys: Machine-wash on a gentle cycle or spot clean with soapy water.